Truce vs the small claims court: cost, time and what you end up with
A small claim costs £35 to £455 to issue plus a hearing fee of up to £346, and small claims took a median 41 weeks to reach trial in mid 2026. Truce aims to settle the same dispute by agreement in days, for a flat fee paid only if both sides sign. If the other side refuses to engage, court remains the route.
| Truce | Small claims court | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Nothing to start. Free when no money is at stake. Money disputes: a flat fee paid only when both sides sign, £29 under £1,000, £79 up to £5,000, £149 up to £10,000 | Issue fee £35 to £455 for claims up to £10,000, plus a hearing fee of £27 to £346 if it goes to a hearing |
| Time | Designed to settle in days | Median 41 weeks from claim to small claims trial (April to June 2026) |
| Who decides | You both do. Nothing is agreed until both sign | A judge decides |
| Tone | Private and calm. Each side is heard separately first | Adversarial. A public record and a hearing |
| Result | A signed agreement with amounts, dates and obligations, tracked to the end | A judgment, which you may still need to enforce |
| If the other side won't take part | Truce cannot force them. You keep a record of your offer | The court can decide without them |
Choose Truce if
- You want the money or the fix, not a verdict
- The relationship matters: a tenant, a neighbour, a client
- You'd rather settle this month than wait most of a year
Choose small claims court if
- The other side has ignored you completely
- You need a judgment you can enforce through the court
- There is a limitation deadline close to expiring
What a small claim really costs
Court fees for money claims rise with the amount: £35 for claims up to £300, rising to £455 for claims between £5,000 and £10,000. If the claim is defended and goes to a hearing, there is a second fee, from £27 for claims up to £300 up to £346 for claims over £3,000.
Fees are only part of it. Most people also lose time preparing bundles, attending a hearing and waiting. In April to June 2026, small claims took a median 41 weeks to reach trial.
Mediation is already part of the court route
Since 2024, defended small claims in England and Wales are referred to a free one hour telephone session with the HMCTS Small Claims Mediation Service. Before that change, the Ministry of Justice reported that 55% of cases that used the service settled, but only 15% to 21% of small claims used it.
In other words: most small disputes settle when people actually talk. Truce brings that conversation to the start, before anyone files a claim.
How Truce is different
One side sends a Truce invite. Each side explains their position privately. Truce helps both sides find terms they can live with, then turns them into a written agreement with amounts, dates and obligations. Once both sign it is a binding contract, and Truce tracks every deadline until it is done.
If one side later breaks a signed agreement, the claim becomes simpler: you are suing on a clear written contract, not arguing the whole dispute again.
Questions
Is Truce cheaper than the small claims court?
Usually. Truce charges a flat fee from £29 only when both sides sign. A defended small claim can cost up to £455 to issue plus up to £346 for the hearing, before your own time.
Do I have to try mediation before going to court?
Defended small claims are now referred to a free one hour mediation session with HMCTS. Courts also expect parties to try to settle before and during a claim.
Can I still go to court if Truce doesn't work?
Yes. Truce does not stop you from making a court claim, and a record of a reasonable offer can help you.
Sources
- GOV.UK, Make a court claim for money: court fees
- GOV.UK, Civil court fees (EX50)
- Ministry of Justice, Civil Justice Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026
- GOV.UK, Mediation baked into the small claims process (22 May 2024)
- Ministry of Justice, Increasing the use of mediation: impact assessment
General information, not legal advice. Fees are as published by each source and can change. Last reviewed November 2026.