Truce vs the deposit scheme dispute service
Every government-backed deposit scheme offers a free dispute service where an adjudicator decides the split on the evidence, usually within weeks. Truce is for landlords and tenants who would rather agree the split themselves, quickly, and keep the relationship. If you cannot agree, the scheme's free service is a good next step.
| Truce | Deposit scheme dispute service | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free when no money is at stake. Money disputes: a flat fee paid only when both sides sign, £29 under £1,000, £79 up to £5,000, £149 up to £10,000 | Free |
| Who decides | Landlord and tenant agree together | An independent adjudicator decides on the evidence |
| Consent | Both sides choose to take part | Both sides usually have to consent to use it |
| Time | Designed to settle in days | For example, DPS: 14 days for evidence, then up to 28 days for a decision |
| Covers | The deposit and anything else: rent arrears, repairs, references, move-out dates | Only the deposit |
Choose Truce if
- You're close to agreeing and want it done this week
- There is more at stake than the deposit
- You want a clean, signed record for both sides
Choose deposit scheme dispute service if
- You can't agree and want a neutral decision for free
- You have strong evidence: inventories, photos, receipts
- The other side won't negotiate
How deposit scheme dispute resolution works
If your deposit was protected in a government-backed scheme, the scheme offers a free dispute resolution service when you disagree about how much should be returned. Landlord and tenant generally have to consent, although consent can be treated as given in some situations, for example when one party is uncooperative.
An adjudicator then decides on the written evidence. At the Deposit Protection Service, for custodial deposits, both sides have 14 days to submit evidence and the adjudicator then has 28 days to decide.
When agreeing beats adjudicating
Adjudication is a decision, not a deal: it can only split the deposit. A Truce agreement can also cover rent arrears, a repair, a reference, a move-out date or a payment plan, and it ends with both sides having said yes.
Questions
Is the deposit scheme dispute service free?
Yes. Government-backed deposit schemes provide their dispute resolution service free to landlords and tenants.
Can I use Truce if my deposit is in a scheme?
Yes. You can agree the split through Truce and then both confirm it with the scheme so the deposit is released.
Sources
- GOV.UK, Tenancy deposit protection: disputes and problems
- Shelter England, Disputes about return of tenancy deposits
- Deposit Protection Service, Dispute resolution timeline
- mydeposits, Tenancy deposit disputes explained
General information, not legal advice. Fees are as published by each source and can change. Last reviewed November 2026.