Pre-launch. Nothing is sent until we open. Join the waitlist
Landlords and tenants5 min read

Tenancy deposit disputes: how to settle without a fight

Short answer

Most deposit disputes are about cleaning and damage, and most can be settled by agreeing a specific split, backed by photos and the check-in inventory, written down and signed by both sides. The deposit schemes offer free adjudication if you cannot agree.

Key facts

How common are deposit disputes?

Formal disputes are a small share of all tenancies, but the number is rising. LegalforLandlords estimates around 46,950 tenancy disputes in England and Wales in 2025, up 11.1% on the year, and the average protected deposit has reached a record £1,175.

What people actually argue about

Cleaning featured in 54% of TDS disputes in 2024 to 2025, and was the leading reason for claims at the DPS in 2025 for the fifth year running.

How to settle it

If you cannot agree, the deposit protection schemes offer free, impartial adjudication. Truce sits one step earlier: a private, neutral negotiation that ends in a signed agreement, often in days.

Why a signed agreement matters

A clear written agreement, with amounts, dates and what happens if a payment is missed, stops the argument restarting. In England and Wales a properly made settlement agreement is a binding contract. Read more in our guide on whether a settlement agreement is legally binding.

Questions

What is the most common reason for deposit disputes?

Cleaning. It featured in 54% of TDS disputes in 2024 to 2025 and was the top reason for claims at the DPS in 2025.

Can a landlord deduct for wear and tear?

No. Landlords can deduct for damage beyond fair wear and tear, cleaning to return the property to its check-in condition, and unpaid rent, but not for normal ageing of the property.

What if we cannot agree on the deposit?

The government-approved deposit protection schemes offer free adjudication. You can also try a neutral negotiation first, such as Truce, and record the outcome in a signed agreement.

Sources

  1. Property Reporter, Tenancy disputes climbing 6% a year (LegalforLandlords analysis)
  2. Property118, Deposit disputes remain rare despite rising rents (TDS, Dec 2025)
  3. NRLA, What 2025 taught us about deposit disputes (TDS adjudication team)
  4. Property Industry Eye, Main cause of tenancy deposit disputes revealed (DPS 2025)
  5. Property118, Cleaning accounts for 65% of deposit disputes (TDS briefing, 2025)

General information, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.

More guides

Don't sue. Send a Truce.

Join the waitlist for UK early access. Free for our first users.

Send a Truce

or just join the waitlist

UK company No. 13326151ICO registered ZC113586Never a cut of your settlementWe never hold your moneyNo legal advice, ever