Tenancy deposit disputes: how to settle without a fight
Most deposit disputes are about cleaning and damage, and most can be settled by agreeing a specific split, backed by photos and the check-in inventory, written down and signed by both sides. The deposit schemes offer free adjudication if you cannot agree.
- Around 46,950 tenancy disputes in England and Wales in 2025
- Record average deposit of £1,175
- Cleaning was involved in 54% of TDS disputes in 2024 to 2025
How common are deposit disputes?
Formal disputes are a small share of all tenancies, but the number is rising. LegalforLandlords estimates around 46,950 tenancy disputes in England and Wales in 2025, up 11.1% on the year, and the average protected deposit has reached a record £1,175.
What people actually argue about
- Cleaning, the most common issue by far
- Damage to fixtures, fittings and flooring
- Redecoration
- Rent arrears at the end of the tenancy
- Gardens and missing items
Cleaning featured in 54% of TDS disputes in 2024 to 2025, and was the leading reason for claims at the DPS in 2025 for the fifth year running.
How to settle it
- Start from the evidence: the check-in inventory, check-out report, photos and receipts.
- Separate fair wear and tear from damage. Landlords cannot charge for normal ageing.
- Put a number on each item instead of arguing about the total.
- Agree a specific split and a date for payment.
- Write it down and both sign it.
If you cannot agree, the deposit protection schemes offer free, impartial adjudication. Truce sits one step earlier: a private, neutral negotiation that ends in a signed agreement, often in days.
Why a signed agreement matters
A clear written agreement, with amounts, dates and what happens if a payment is missed, stops the argument restarting. In England and Wales a properly made settlement agreement is a binding contract. Read more in our guide on whether a settlement agreement is legally binding.
Questions
What is the most common reason for deposit disputes?
Cleaning. It featured in 54% of TDS disputes in 2024 to 2025 and was the top reason for claims at the DPS in 2025.
Can a landlord deduct for wear and tear?
No. Landlords can deduct for damage beyond fair wear and tear, cleaning to return the property to its check-in condition, and unpaid rent, but not for normal ageing of the property.
What if we cannot agree on the deposit?
The government-approved deposit protection schemes offer free adjudication. You can also try a neutral negotiation first, such as Truce, and record the outcome in a signed agreement.
Sources
- Property Reporter, Tenancy disputes climbing 6% a year (LegalforLandlords analysis)
- Property118, Deposit disputes remain rare despite rising rents (TDS, Dec 2025)
- NRLA, What 2025 taught us about deposit disputes (TDS adjudication team)
- Property Industry Eye, Main cause of tenancy deposit disputes revealed (DPS 2025)
- Property118, Cleaning accounts for 65% of deposit disputes (TDS briefing, 2025)
General information, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.