Businesses4 min read

How to respond to a bad review (and stay within the law)

Short answer

Reply in public within a day, briefly and without arguing, and offer a private, fair way to fix the problem. Never make a refund or gift depend on changing or removing the review: the UK bans concealing negative reviews from 6 April 2025, and the US FTC rule bans review suppression from 21 October 2024. Fix the problem, not the review.

Key facts

A reply that works

Thank them, say sorry it went wrong, and offer a fair fix in private. One or two sentences. No excuses, no details of their visit, no blame.

Example: "Thank you for telling us, and we're sorry this went wrong. We'd like to put it right fairly. If you're happy to, tell your side here in private and a neutral mediator will suggest a fair fix: [link]"

What not to do

Before the review

Most bad reviews start as a problem nobody fixed. Give customers an easy, private way to tell you on the spot: a card on the table, a line on the receipt, a link in the post-visit email. Always add that they can still leave a review anytime.

How Truce helps

Truce is a neutral mediator. The customer tells their side in private, Truce proposes a fair fix, and you both sign. It's free for the customer, the review stays theirs, and humans have the final say. Start at trucehq.com/reviews.

Questions

Can I pay a customer to remove a bad review?

Don't. Making an offer depend on removing or changing a review risks breaking UK and US consumer law. Settle the complaint, not the review.

Should I reply to every bad review?

Yes, briefly and kindly. A calm reply with an offer to fix things tells future customers more than the review does.

Can the customer still review after a Truce?

Yes. Nothing in a Truce can depend on the review.

Sources

  1. CMA, Fake reviews guidance (CMA208, 4 April 2025)
  2. ASA, Fake consumer reviews (CAP Code rules from 6 April 2025)
  3. FTC, Final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (14 August 2024)
  4. Federal Register, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR 465)

General information, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.

More guides

Don't sue. Send a Truce.

Free unless money is involved. Sent on WhatsApp in two minutes.

Send a Truce