How to respond to a bad review (and stay within the law)
Reply in public within a day, briefly and without arguing, and offer a private, fair way to fix the problem. Never make a refund or gift depend on changing or removing the review: the UK bans concealing negative reviews from 6 April 2025, and the US FTC rule bans review suppression from 21 October 2024. Fix the problem, not the review.
- Reply publicly, calmly and quickly; future customers read your reply more than the review.
- Offer a private way to put it right.
- Never condition an offer on removing or changing a review.
- UK: the DMCC Act 2024 bans fake reviews and concealing negative ones (from 6 April 2025).
- US: the FTC rule bans review suppression by threats or intimidation (from 21 October 2024).
A reply that works
Thank them, say sorry it went wrong, and offer a fair fix in private. One or two sentences. No excuses, no details of their visit, no blame.
Example: "Thank you for telling us, and we're sorry this went wrong. We'd like to put it right fairly. If you're happy to, tell your side here in private and a neutral mediator will suggest a fair fix: [link]"
What not to do
- Don't offer anything in exchange for deleting or editing the review.
- Don't threaten legal action to get a review removed.
- Don't only invite happy customers to review, or hide the unhappy ones.
- Don't argue the facts in public.
Before the review
Most bad reviews start as a problem nobody fixed. Give customers an easy, private way to tell you on the spot: a card on the table, a line on the receipt, a link in the post-visit email. Always add that they can still leave a review anytime.
How Truce helps
Truce is a neutral mediator. The customer tells their side in private, Truce proposes a fair fix, and you both sign. It's free for the customer, the review stays theirs, and humans have the final say. Start at trucehq.com/reviews.
Questions
Can I pay a customer to remove a bad review?
Don't. Making an offer depend on removing or changing a review risks breaking UK and US consumer law. Settle the complaint, not the review.
Should I reply to every bad review?
Yes, briefly and kindly. A calm reply with an offer to fix things tells future customers more than the review does.
Can the customer still review after a Truce?
Yes. Nothing in a Truce can depend on the review.
Sources
- CMA, Fake reviews guidance (CMA208, 4 April 2025)
- ASA, Fake consumer reviews (CAP Code rules from 6 April 2025)
- FTC, Final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (14 August 2024)
- Federal Register, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR 465)
General information, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.